recent curated

news posts

 

Architecture

Book Review: The Heights permalink

Source: feedproxy.google.com

d:r feed network / (0) / posted over 1 year ago / flag this / read more

The Heights: Anatomy of a Skyscraper by Kate Ascher
Penguin, 2011
Hardcover, 208 pages

book-ascher1.jpg

In 2005's The Works, Kate Ascher presented the "Anatomy of a City" through an abundance of explanatory diagrams, details, and other illustrations alongside her thorough yet readable text. The book described how something as complex as a city actually works by dissecting one in particular: New York City. It is an exceptional book for being both educational and beautiful, a combination that makes the information understandable for a general audience. Her follow-up, The Heights, follows the formula of its predecessor, and it can be seen to pick up where the infrastructure of the city leaves off: at its buildings, specifically skyscrapers.

book-ascher2.jpg
[Supertall building diagram from the Introduction to The Heights by Kate Ascher]

While The Works used a specific metropolis to discuss cities in general, The Heights inverts that and presents general information so readers can understand what skyscrapers as a typology have in common. So Ascher does not dissect just the Burj Khalifa (far right in the above diagram), for example, as a case study in skyscrapers. By describing the systems, components, and other considerations that go into the design and construction of tall buildings, the idiosyncrasies of a single skyscraper can be either set aside or touched upon in a sidebar. This approach is helpful, for it enables the book to be structured via these various pieces (structure, construction, elevators, sustainability, etc.), and it results in a broader understanding of what it takes to build tall; or even to build in general, such is the extensive range of the information. Of course some aspects of design and construction, liked tuned mass dampers (below), are so specific to tall buildings that some architects have exploited them in their designs, and Ascher has presented them as such.

book-ascher3.jpg
[Excerpt from Dampers diagram in "Building It" chapter in The Heights by Kate Ascher]

Ascher closes the book with a chapter on the future, which looks at building taller, greener, more sculpturally, and as cities within cities. Like anything this future is partially written by what has already happened, be it from decades ago (Chicago's John Hancock Tower is an example of a city within a city from the 1970s) or even millennia. Yes, millennia. Ascher presents a couple projects that imagine pyramid-like forms for building taller and taller for more and more people. The inclusion of these projects ultimately brings into question the defining characteristics of skyscrapers, namely the height-to-width ratio. Is it just about pushing humanity further and further up, regardless of form? Whatever the case may be, these pyramidal designs are so big and populous, they are such a strong break from the prevailing skyscraper typology, that a lot of what Ascher presents would need to be reconsidered. They would more literally become cities within cities, or to put it another way, they would synthesize The Works and The Heights.

US: Buy from Amazon.com CA: Buy from Amazon.ca UK: Buy from Amazon.co.uk

(On a side note, having worked on the design of tall buildings, I must admit that while reading the book I relived some of the arguments, setbacks, errors, and other problems that happened in the coordination of something so complex, something with such a large number of players. Headaches are par for the course in all architectural projects, but frustration can be amplified with tall buildings because repetition of floor plates should help simplify things; it doesn't. I'm guessing twisting towers and other formal strategies that add variation to just about every floor will change this to migraines. Regardless, Ascher's book has such a strong logic to it -- in the details as well as in the big picture -- that this frustration does not come across.)



Add your dialogue below. Simple html (‹b›‹i›‹em›‹strong›) is OK, but make sure to preview your comment first! Oh, and please be nice!


 

related content

News posts

 

Book Review: The Heights

 
 

Book Review: The Transparent City

 
 

Book Review: The L!brary Book

 
 

Book Review: The Most Human Human

 
 

Book Review: The Language of Towns & Cities

 
 

Book Review: The Glass House

 
 

Two Magazines

 
 

Book Review: The Architect Says

 
 

Book Review: The Light Pavilion

 
 

Social Historian: Sunday Book Review

 
 

Links

 
 

Plans for New Book Review Site

 
 

Motionographer reviews the book, “Uncredited”

 
 

Book Review: Ellington Boulevard

 
 

Book Review: Cost-Effective Buildings

 
 
 

Projects

 
The New York Times Book Review

The New York Times Book Review

 
 
The Book of Night Women

The Book of Night Women

 
 
Horse Soldiers

Horse Soldiers

 
 
The Future of Liberalism / A Tolerable Anarchy

The Future of Liberalism / A Tolerable Anarchy

 
 
Power Rules

Power Rules

 
 
The Hacker and the Hacked

The Hacker and the Hacked

 
 
NYT Book Review - Blowing Their Own Cover

NYT Book Review - Blowing Their Own Cover

 
 
New York Times Book Review

New York Times Book Review

 
 
Little Children

Little Children

 
 
Spam (3598): artist book about the presence of spam in the inbox

Spam (3598): artist book about the presence of spam in the inbox

 
 
I am: Artist book about the presence of identity on the internet

I am: Artist book about the presence of identity on the internet

 
 
omg wtf?: Artist book about the use of acronyms in digital communication

omg wtf?: Artist book about the use of acronyms in digital communication

 
 
Florian Del Cassonetto

Florian Del Cassonetto

 
 
La Foresta Di New York

La Foresta Di New York

 
 
Bur Sessanta

Bur Sessanta

 
 
 

Inspirations

 
Michael Sieben and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz

Michael Sieben and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz

 
 
Notes from Russia: Hand-Made Street Notices

Notes from Russia: Hand-Made Street Notices

 
 
Jacket of

Jacket of "The Gone-Away World" by Nick Harkaway

 
 
The Great Reindeer Rebellion

The Great Reindeer Rebellion

 
 
Papercraft: Design and Art with Paper book

Papercraft: Design and Art with Paper book

 
 

"The Clock Without a Face," a Gus Twintig mystery book

 
 
Art of McSweeney's book and dust jacket

Art of McSweeney's book and dust jacket

 
 
The 10 Best Books of 2007

The 10 Best Books of 2007

 
 
AIGA Paperbacks U.S.A. 1959/1961

AIGA Paperbacks U.S.A. 1959/1961

 
 
Love Poems by Pablo Neruda, 2008 edition

Love Poems by Pablo Neruda, 2008 edition

 
 
Book design by McSweeney’s

Book design by McSweeney’s

 
 
Soon I Will Be Invincible

Soon I Will Be Invincible

 
 
Book Autopsies - Brian Dettmer

Book Autopsies - Brian Dettmer

 
 
Fully Booked: Cover Art and Design for Books from Gestalten Verlag

Fully Booked: Cover Art and Design for Books from Gestalten Verlag

 
 
Phaidon's Le Corbusier LeGrand

Phaidon's Le Corbusier LeGrand