recent curated

news posts

 

Architecture

Book Review: Travels in the History of Architecture permalink

Source: feedproxy.google.com

d:r feed network / (0) / posted over 3 years ago / flag this / read more

Travels in the History of Architecture by Robert Harbison
Reaktion Books, 2010
Hardcover, 288 pages

book-harbison.jpg

Histories of architecture are quite a particular bunch. Known by their authors -- Trachtenberg and Hyman, Sir Banister Fletcher -- the large-format and heavily illustrated books chronologically trace major buildings in Western history, from Egypt to Post-Modernism. Geared primarily to architecture students, these and other textbook-like histories take an art-historical approach to cataloging and describing buildings based on aesthetic and formal grounds. So Greek architecture is looked at in terms of the orders and proportions; Roman architecture, the arch; Gothic architecture, groin vaults and flying buttresses, and so forth. These are incomplete histories that ignore that developments are not always linear, skipping decades or more. They also play down the social, economic, political (minus important leaders and clients), and other contextual factors that influence architecture and its many forms.

As I started Robert Harbison's compact book on the history of architecture, it sounded like he was writing the anti-history, taking the opposite position of the above books to create an idiosyncratic though no less understandable presentation of architecture's past; small instead of big, lesser known buildings instead of masterpieces, nonlinear instead of chronological. But shortly after the book's first sentence a more subtle tactic is presented: "Perhaps I simply hope to rewrite the canon, not to topple it, perhaps only (some of the time at least) to give new reasons for the inclusion of the same old monuments." Having read a few of Harbison's books previously (Eccentric Spaces; The Built, the Unbuilt, and the Unbuildable; Thirteen Ways; all recommended), I didn't think this would be a bad thing. His insight and prose, rooted in experience and the articulation and expression of it, paint vivid pictures of places and present unexpected points-of-view. His vertiginous description of ascending into the dome of St. Paul's in London comes to mind.

Like the histories of Trachtenberg & Hyman and Fletcher, Harbison starts in Egypt, and he ends with Deoncstruction. Also similar are the chronology of the chapters and the focus on Western architecture, mostly Western Europe. Yet a chronology in the vein of Romanesque beget Gothic, Renaissance beget Mannerism, is questioned in the writing, looking at original sources, other histories, and first-hand experience. In the case of the last -- which informs the focus on Western Europe, where Harbison has traveled most and knows best -- sometimes unexpected details come to the fore rather than the architectural elements we've learned to appreciate elsewhere. It is these moments of elucidating a style or movement from canonical works that stand out in Harbison's "rewriting."

US: Buy from     Amazon.com CA: Buy from     Amazon.ca UK: Buy from     Amazon.co.uk



Add your dialogue below. Simple html (‹b›‹i›‹em›‹strong›) is OK, but make sure to preview your comment first! Oh, and please be nice!


 

related content

News posts

 

Book Review: Travels in the History of Architecture

 
 

Monday, Monday

 
 

Monday, Monday

 
 

Behemoths of the Moment

 
 

Eduardo Souto de Moura wins Pritzker Prize

 
 

Book Review: ARCHIZINES

 
 

28 in 28 #27: a+t 39-40

 
 

Books: Airworld. Design and Architecture for Air Travel

 
 

The Invisible Hook

 
 

Books: Case Study Houses

 
 

Zumthor Book of the Moment

 
 

Books: Rock the Shack: The Architecture of Cabins, Cocoons and Hide-Outs

 
 

Touch: Estúdio Manus

 
 

AE1: Residential Rooftop Sun Filter

 
 

BIO 21 - The selection has been made for the international exhibition

 
 
 

Projects

 
A Short History of the United States

A Short History of the United States

 
 
In The Shelter of His Wings

In The Shelter of His Wings

 
 
In the Kingdom of Invisible Women

In the Kingdom of Invisible Women

 
 
In the Land of Invisible Women

In the Land of Invisible Women

 
 
So bad that it comes all the way back around to not selling.

So bad that it comes all the way back around to not selling.

 
 
In the Shadow of the Cypress

In the Shadow of the Cypress

 
 
In The Shadow of Freedom

In The Shadow of Freedom

 
 
In the Carnival of Breathing

In the Carnival of Breathing

 
 
The New York Times Book Review

The New York Times Book Review

 
 
A Genius for Place

A Genius for Place

 
 
Lifelines in World History Vol. 1-3

Lifelines in World History Vol. 1-3

 
 
A Brief History of Time

A Brief History of Time

 
 
The Anti-Journalist

The Anti-Journalist

 
 
A Splintered History of Wood

A Splintered History of Wood

 
 
His & Her Book Covers

His & Her Book Covers

 
 
 

Inspirations

 
Fully Booked: Ink on Paper

Fully Booked: Ink on Paper

 
 
Long Tack Sam

Long Tack Sam

 
 
AIGA Paperbacks U.S.A. 1959/1961

AIGA Paperbacks U.S.A. 1959/1961

 
 

"Born Modern: The Life and Design of Alvin Lustig" book

 
 
Still Life…Still Hope by Kenneth Hope

Still Life…Still Hope by Kenneth Hope

 
 
Gateways: International Book Covers Exhibit and Catalog

Gateways: International Book Covers Exhibit and Catalog

 
 
A Music So Subtle and Vast by Carey Gough

A Music So Subtle and Vast by Carey Gough

 
 
there’s much more to Alvin Lustig

there’s much more to Alvin Lustig

 
 
Zoomscape

Zoomscape

 
 
The Green Box

The Green Box

 
 
Fully Booked: Cover Art and Design for Books from Gestalten Verlag

Fully Booked: Cover Art and Design for Books from Gestalten Verlag

 
 
Phaidon's Le Corbusier LeGrand

Phaidon's Le Corbusier LeGrand

 
 
The Art of Romance: Mills & Boon and Harlequin Cover Designs book

The Art of Romance: Mills & Boon and Harlequin Cover Designs book

 
 
Women of Design: Influence and Inspiration book

Women of Design: Influence and Inspiration book

 
 
Oded Ezer: The Typographer's Guide to the Galaxy book

Oded Ezer: The Typographer's Guide to the Galaxy book